Alex is Sprintlaw's co-founder and a legal technology leader. He holds law and media degrees from the University of Sydney and has been recognized by Australasian Lawyer, Lawyers Weekly and the Sydney Young Entrepreneur Awards for his work building Sprintlaw and improving access to business legal support.
- What Does Unlimited Liability Mean in a Customer Contract?
- Why Might a Customer Request Uncapped Liability?
- What Should You Check Before Accepting Unlimited Liability?
- Can You Negotiate a Liability Cap Instead?
- What Are Carve-Outs, and When Might Liability Remain Uncapped?
- Are Unlimited Liability Clauses Enforceable in the US?
- What If the Customer Refuses to Change the Liability Clause?
- Key Takeaways
- How Can Sprintlaw Help?
In business, you don't expect everyone to be out to get you. However, it doesn't always take bad intentions for something to seriously damage your business. Sometimes, all it takes is a contract with terms that don't work in your favour.
Say you've just secured a new customer. It's a great opportunity, the project is worth $20,000 and everything seems to be going smoothly. Then, the customer sends over their standard agreement, which includes a requirement for your business to accept unlimited liability.
You might not think much of it at first. After all, you're confident in the services you're providing, and you don't anticipate anything going wrong.
But what happens if something does go wrong, and the customer claims they've suffered losses worth far more than the amount they're paying you?
Suddenly, a $20,000 project could leave your business exposed to a much larger financial claim.
So, does accepting a customer's contract mean you have to accept unlimited liability, or can you negotiate terms that better protect your business?
What Does Unlimited Liability Mean in a Customer Contract?
Unlimited liability means there's no agreed financial cap on the amount your business could be required to pay for certain claims under a contract.
Normally, a contract might include a limitation of liability clause, which sets a maximum amount that one party can be held financially responsible for if something goes wrong.
For instance, if you're providing $20,000 worth of services, the agreement might limit your total liability to $20,000. Without that protection, your potential financial exposure could be considerably higher.
However, unlimited liability doesn't mean your customer can simply demand any amount they like and expect you to pay it. They would still need to establish a valid legal claim, and other contractual provisions or legal principles may restrict what they can recover.
The concern is that, without an effective liability cap, your business may have less protection against a substantial claim.
For more information, see our guide to limitation of liability clauses in US contracts.
Why Might a Customer Request Uncapped Liability?
A customer asking for unlimited liability isn't necessarily trying to take advantage of your business. In some cases, they may have legitimate concerns about the risks associated with the services you're providing.
Consider a software company working with a larger organisation. If a security failure exposes sensitive customer information, the consequences could extend well beyond the value of the software agreement.
The customer might face regulatory investigations, third-party claims, remediation expenses or operational disruptions. They may therefore want the software provider to accept responsibility for certain losses arising from its services.
Similar concerns can arise with intellectual property infringement, confidentiality breaches or other risks that aren't necessarily reflected in the contract price.
However, there's an important distinction between accepting responsibility for your work and agreeing to potentially unlimited financial exposure.
A customer's preferred terms might protect their interests, but they could also place a disproportionate amount of risk on a smaller supplier.
What Should You Check Before Accepting Unlimited Liability?
Before agreeing to unlimited liability, it's important to understand exactly what you're being asked to take responsibility for.
Start by looking at the scope of the liability. Does unlimited liability apply to every contractual breach, or only specific circumstances, such as confidentiality breaches or intellectual property infringement?
There's a significant difference between accepting unlimited liability for any contractual mistake and accepting it for a narrowly defined category of serious misconduct.
Next, consider the potential financial consequences. A relatively small contract could involve services that affect the customer's operations, data or relationships with third parties. The contract price alone may not reflect the potential exposure.
Insurance is another important consideration. Professional liability insurance, cyber insurance or other policies may protect your business against certain claims. However, coverage is subject to policy limits, exclusions and conditions.
For example, even if your business has $1 million in professional liability insurance, that doesn't necessarily mean every liability you've agreed to accept under a customer contract will be covered. Contractual obligations can sometimes extend beyond what an insurer is prepared to pay.
It's also important to check for indemnification provisions elsewhere in the agreement.
An indemnification clause can require your business to compensate another party for specified losses or claims. However, an indemnity isn't automatically uncapped simply because it's an indemnity. Whether it falls within or outside the agreement's general liability cap depends on the wording.
This is why reviewing the entire agreement matters, not just the clause labelled "limitation of liability."
Can You Negotiate a Liability Cap Instead?
Yes. Just because a customer has included unlimited liability in their standard agreement doesn't mean you can't propose alternative terms.
One approach is to suggest a liability cap that reflects the value of the contract and the risks involved.
For example, your business might propose limiting its total liability to the fees paid or payable under the agreement. Alternatively, the parties might agree to a higher amount, such as twice the contract value.
Consider a software provider entering a $30,000 agreement. The customer initially requests unlimited liability for all breaches, but the supplier proposes a general cap based on the contract fees, with a higher, separate limit for certain data security claims.
This doesn't guarantee the customer will agree, but it provides a starting point for discussing how the financial risks should be shared.
The wording of the cap also matters. A clause limiting liability to fees paid during the previous 12 months could produce a different result from one based on the total value of a multi-year agreement.
You should also consider whether the cap applies to all claims combined or separately to each claim. A single aggregate cap can provide greater certainty than a limit that effectively resets whenever a new claim arises.
There's no universally appropriate liability cap. What works for one business may not be suitable for another, particularly where the services, potential losses and insurance arrangements differ.
What Are Carve-Outs, and When Might Liability Remain Uncapped?
Sometimes, a customer will agree to a general liability cap but insist that certain circumstances remain outside it.
These exceptions are known as carve-outs.
For example, an agreement might limit liability for ordinary contractual breaches while excluding certain categories of claims from that protection.
Commonly discussed carve-outs include fraud, willful misconduct, gross negligence, confidentiality breaches, intellectual property infringement and certain indemnification obligations.
However, these exceptions aren't automatically required in every contract. Their appropriateness and enforceability depend on the circumstances, the agreement and applicable state law.
For a small business, accepting unlimited liability for every confidentiality or intellectual property issue could still create considerable exposure.
An alternative might be to negotiate a higher, separate cap for specific risks, sometimes called a super-cap.
For instance, the parties could agree to a general liability cap equal to the contract fees, with a higher limit for certain data security obligations.
This can provide the customer with additional protection while avoiding unlimited liability for every exception.
Are Unlimited Liability Clauses Enforceable in the US?
Generally, businesses entering commercial contracts in the US have considerable freedom to agree on how financial risks will be allocated. This can include agreeing to liability provisions without a financial cap.
However, contract law is primarily governed by individual state laws, and the enforceability of liability limitations, exclusions and related provisions can be affected by statutory restrictions and public policy.
For example, in Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. v. Noble Lowndes International, Inc., 84 N.Y.2d 430 (1994), the New York Court of Appeals considered a contractual provision excluding consequential damages, subject to exceptions involving certain serious misconduct.
The court examined what the parties intended by the exception for "willful acts" and upheld the limitation in the circumstances. The decision illustrates how important the precise wording of liability exclusions and exceptions can be.
However, this was a decision concerning New York law and the interpretation of a damages limitation, rather than a nationwide ruling on unlimited liability clauses.
The important point is that you shouldn't assume an unfavourable liability provision will be unenforceable simply because it seems excessive.
Equally, a contractual liability cap won't necessarily protect your business against every claim. The applicable law, wording of the agreement and nature of the alleged wrongdoing all matter.
It's generally better to understand these risks before signing than to rely on a court to resolve an unfavourable provision later.
What If the Customer Refuses to Change the Liability Clause?
Sometimes, a customer will insist on their standard terms, particularly where they're a larger organisation with established procurement requirements.
However, your options aren't necessarily limited to accepting the agreement as written or walking away.
Even if the customer won't agree to a general liability cap, there may be opportunities to narrow particular obligations, limit certain indemnities or introduce a higher cap for specific risks.
You might also consider whether the agreement excludes certain categories of damages, such as consequential damages.
This is different from a financial liability cap. A cap limits the amount that may be recovered, while a damages exclusion restricts particular types of recoverable losses. Whether a loss is classified as direct or consequential can depend on the facts, contract wording and applicable law.
Changes to the project scope, responsibilities or services being provided might also help make the arrangement more manageable.
However, there may still be situations where the customer isn't prepared to make meaningful changes.
In that case, it's worth considering whether the commercial value of the opportunity justifies the remaining risk.
Winning a valuable contract is important, but so is making sure that one agreement doesn't put the rest of your business at unnecessary risk.
Key Takeaways
Unlimited liability provisions aren't always unreasonable, but they deserve careful consideration, particularly where the potential financial consequences could significantly exceed the value of the contract.
Before accepting these terms, it's worth understanding exactly what you're responsible for, whether your insurance provides adequate protection and whether a liability cap or narrower carve-out could better reflect the risks involved.
A customer requesting unlimited liability doesn't necessarily mean you have to accept it. Even where they have standard contractual requirements, there may be room to discuss how financial responsibility is allocated.
The important thing is to understand what you're agreeing to before the contract becomes binding.
How Can Sprintlaw Help?
If a customer has asked you to accept unlimited liability, it's worth taking a closer look at what that could mean for your business before signing.
A legal expert can help you understand how the liability provisions work alongside the rest of your agreement, identify any unexpected risks and determine whether the terms provide reasonable protection for your business.
Whether you're reviewing a customer's proposed contract or preparing your own agreement, having the right terms in place can help prevent costly misunderstandings later on.
If you would like a consultation on your options moving forward, you can reach us at (888) 449-8437 or team@sprintlaw.com for a free, no-obligations chat.








