Alex is Sprintlaw's co-founder and a legal technology leader. He holds law and media degrees from the University of Sydney and has been recognized by Australasian Lawyer, Lawyers Weekly and the Sydney Young Entrepreneur Awards for his work building Sprintlaw and improving access to business legal support.
Contents
Nonprofit founders and operators often underestimate the importance of nonprofit bylaws when starting or running an organization in the United States. Common mistakes include copying bylaws from unrelated organizations, failing to update them as the nonprofit grows, or misunderstanding who has the authority to approve changes. These errors can lead to confusion, disputes among board members, or even regulatory problems with the IRS or state authorities. This guide answers the most pressing questions about nonprofit bylaws, including who "owns" them, how they are approved and amended, what recordkeeping is required, and how state law can affect your obligations. We will provide practical checklists, highlight frequent mistakes, and offer examples to help you avoid pitfalls and keep your nonprofit on solid legal footing.
What Are Nonprofit Bylaws?
Nonprofit bylaws are the core set of internal rules that define how your organization is governed and operated. They serve as the nonprofit's operating manual, providing structure for decision-making, authority, and accountability. Bylaws are not typically filed with the IRS, but they are required by nearly every state and are essential for maintaining both tax-exempt status and good standing with regulators.
Key components of nonprofit bylaws usually include:
- Board of directors structure, election, and terms
- Officer roles, duties, and succession
- Procedures for calling and conducting meetings
- Voting rights and quorum requirements
- Membership rules (if applicable)
- Conflict of interest policies
- Processes for amending the bylaws
Bylaws are distinct from the articles of incorporation, which are filed with your state to legally form the nonprofit. Articles are generally brief and formal, while bylaws provide the detailed rules for how the organization operates day-to-day. The IRS will often request a copy of your bylaws when you apply for 501(c)(3) status or during an audit. State agencies may also ask for them during registration or compliance checks, especially in states like California, New York, and Illinois.
For example, a nonprofit focused on youth education might set bylaws that require at least three board members, specify annual elections, and establish a process for removing directors for misconduct. These details help prevent disputes and ensure the organization runs smoothly.
Checklist: What Should Nonprofit Bylaws Include?
- Name and purpose of the organization
- Board composition, terms, and election process
- Officer positions and responsibilities
- Meeting frequency, notice, and quorum
- Voting procedures
- Membership requirements (if any)
- Conflict of interest policy
- Amendment procedures
- Dissolution process
Failing to address these points can result in confusion, legal disputes, or loss of tax-exempt status.
Who Owns Nonprofit Bylaws?
Nonprofits do not have owners or shareholders. Instead, the board of directors is responsible for governing the organization and ensuring it fulfills its mission. The bylaws are "owned" in the sense that the board controls them: they are adopted, amended, and interpreted by the board, unless the bylaws themselves or state law give members a role in approving changes.
Board Authority: In most nonprofits, the board of directors has the exclusive authority to adopt, amend, or repeal bylaws. This is typically stated in the bylaws themselves. For example, the bylaws might say, "The board may amend these bylaws by a two-thirds vote at any regular meeting, provided notice is given."
Membership Organizations: If your nonprofit has voting members (not just board members), the bylaws may grant members the right to approve certain changes. This is common in trade associations, religious organizations, and clubs. For example, a national professional association may require a majority of its voting members to approve changes to the bylaws at an annual meeting.
State Law Requirements: Some states require specific provisions in bylaws or mandate member approval for certain amendments. For example, in New York, the Not-for-Profit Corporation Law requires member approval for changes affecting member voting rights. In California, the Nonprofit Public Benefit Corporation Law has detailed rules about amending bylaws and the rights of members.
Practical Example: A nonprofit animal shelter in Illinois has a board of five directors. The bylaws state that amendments require a two-thirds board vote. However, the shelter later adds members who pay annual dues. The board wants to change the bylaws to increase dues, but Illinois law and the existing bylaws require member approval for changes that affect membership rights. The board must hold a member vote before making the change.
Common Mistakes:
- Assuming the founder "owns" the bylaws after the initial board is formed
- Failing to specify who can amend the bylaws, leading to disputes
- Not updating all copies after amendments, causing confusion
- Overlooking state law requirements for member approval
To avoid these mistakes, clearly state in your bylaws who has the authority to amend them and follow any state law requirements for member involvement.
How Are Nonprofit Bylaws Approved And Amended?
Approval and amendment of bylaws is a formal process that must be documented in your meeting minutes and organizational records. The process typically involves several steps, and requirements can vary based on your bylaws and state law.
Initial Adoption: When a nonprofit is first formed, the incorporators or the initial board of directors adopt the bylaws at an organizational meeting. This action is recorded in the first set of board minutes. For example, the minutes might state, "The board unanimously adopted the bylaws as presented."
Amendments: After initial adoption, the bylaws can be amended according to the procedure specified in the bylaws themselves. This usually requires a majority or supermajority vote of the board, and sometimes advance notice to all directors or members. For example, your bylaws might require a two-thirds board vote and seven days' written notice before an amendment can be considered.
Member Approval: If your nonprofit has voting members, the bylaws or state law may require member approval for certain amendments. For example, changes to the number of directors, membership rights, or voting procedures may need a member vote. In some states, such as Massachusetts, member approval is mandatory for amendments that affect member voting rights.
State Law Caveats: State nonprofit corporation acts may impose additional requirements. For example:
- California requires advance notice to members for certain bylaw changes and may require member approval for amendments affecting member rights.
- New York requires a two-thirds board vote for some amendments and member approval for others.
- Texas allows the board to amend bylaws unless the articles or bylaws reserve this power to members.
Checklist: Approving or Amending Bylaws
- Review the amendment procedure in your current bylaws
- Draft the proposed changes in writing
- Provide required notice to directors and/or members
- Hold a formal meeting and record the vote in the minutes
- Update the master copy and distribute to all relevant parties
- File updated bylaws with state regulators if required
Example: A youth sports nonprofit in California wants to change its board election process. The bylaws require a two-thirds board vote and 10 days' notice to all members. The board sends written notice, holds a meeting, and records the vote in the minutes. After approval, the organization updates its records and files the new bylaws with the California Attorney General as part of its annual registration.
Common Mistakes:
- Making informal changes without a formal vote or proper notice
- Ignoring member approval requirements
- Failing to update state filings after amendments
- Overlooking state-specific procedures for bylaw changes
To avoid these issues, always follow your bylaws' amendment process and check your state's nonprofit laws before making changes.
Recordkeeping Requirements For Nonprofit Bylaws
Proper recordkeeping is essential for legal compliance and organizational transparency. Both the IRS and state regulators expect nonprofits to maintain accurate and up-to-date records, including bylaws and amendments.
Federal Requirements: The IRS requires 501(c)(3) organizations to keep a copy of their current bylaws and any amendments. You may need to provide these when applying for tax-exempt status (Form 1023 or 1024), during an IRS audit, or in response to a compliance review. The IRS also expects you to maintain board meeting minutes that document bylaw adoption and amendments.
State Requirements: Most states require nonprofits to keep bylaws at their principal office. Some states, such as New York, California, and Florida, may require you to submit a copy with your initial registration or annual filings. For example, California requires public benefit corporations to provide bylaws to the Attorney General upon request and to update filings after amendments.
Internal Records: Keep detailed board meeting minutes that document the adoption and amendment of bylaws. These minutes are often requested by funders, auditors, or regulators. It is also good practice to keep a record of all versions of the bylaws, with dates and approval details, to track changes over time.
Accessibility: Make sure all board members and, if applicable, voting members have access to the current bylaws. Many nonprofits store digital copies in secure, shared folders and maintain a printed master copy at the principal office.
Checklist: Nonprofit Bylaw Recordkeeping
- Maintain a master copy of the current bylaws, signed and dated
- Keep a record of all amendments, with dates and approval details
- Store board meeting minutes related to bylaw changes
- Update state filings if required after amendments
- Ensure bylaws are accessible to those entitled to see them
- Retain old versions for historical reference
Example: A nonprofit in Florida amends its bylaws to change the number of directors. The board records the amendment in the meeting minutes, updates the master copy, and files the new bylaws with the Florida Department of State as part of its annual renewal. The organization keeps both the old and new versions in its records for reference.
Common Mistakes:
- Losing track of amendments or failing to keep signed copies
- Not updating state filings after bylaw changes
- Having conflicting versions in circulation
- Failing to provide access to current bylaws for board or members
To avoid these problems, establish a clear process for updating, storing, and sharing bylaws and related records.
Common Mistakes And How To Avoid Them
Nonprofit founders and boards frequently make avoidable mistakes with bylaws. Recognizing these issues early can save time, money, and legal headaches.
- Copying bylaws from unrelated organizations: Every nonprofit is unique. Using a generic template can result in rules that do not fit your mission, structure, or state law requirements. For example, bylaws copied from a California charity may not comply with Texas law.
- Leaving out key provisions: Missing details about board terms, officer duties, or conflict of interest policies can create confusion and risk. For instance, failing to specify how directors are removed can lead to disputes if a board member is not fulfilling their duties.
- Failing to follow amendment procedures: Making informal changes without a formal vote or proper notice can make amendments invalid and expose the organization to legal challenges.
- Not updating records: Keeping outdated versions or failing to update state filings can cause compliance problems and confusion among board members or regulators.
- Ignoring state-specific rules: State nonprofit laws may require specific language or procedures. Failing to comply can jeopardize your standing or tax-exempt status.
Checklist: Avoiding Bylaw Pitfalls
- Use a bylaw checklist tailored to your state and type of nonprofit
- Consult with a legal professional familiar with nonprofit law
- Review bylaws regularly and update them as your organization evolves
- Document all changes and keep records organized and accessible
- Communicate changes clearly to all board members and, if applicable, members
Example Scenario: A new nonprofit in Texas copied bylaws from a California charity, not realizing that Texas law requires different procedures for board meetings and member voting. When a dispute arose over the removal of a director, the board had no clear answer and had to consult legal counsel to resolve the issue and amend the bylaws properly. This delayed important decisions and created tension among board members.
To prevent similar problems, always tailor your bylaws to your organization's needs and your state's legal requirements. Regularly review and update your bylaws as your nonprofit grows or as laws change.
FAQs
Do nonprofit bylaws need to be filed with the IRS?
No, nonprofit bylaws are not filed with the IRS as a project of course. However, you must submit a copy when applying for tax-exempt status (Form 1023 or 1024), and the IRS may request them during an audit or compliance review. Always keep your bylaws current and accessible.
Are nonprofit bylaws public record?
Bylaws are not automatically public record at the federal level. Some states require you to file bylaws with your initial registration or make them available upon request. Many nonprofits choose to make their bylaws public for transparency, especially if they receive public funding or donations. For example, California and New York may require public disclosure of bylaws upon request.
How often should nonprofit bylaws be reviewed?
It is good practice to review your bylaws every two to three years, or whenever there is a significant change in your organization's structure, mission, or state law. Regular reviews help ensure your bylaws remain relevant and compliant with current laws.
Can nonprofit bylaws be changed by the board alone?
In most nonprofits, the board of directors can amend the bylaws, unless the bylaws or state law require member approval for certain changes. Always check your bylaws and state nonprofit laws before making amendments. For example, in membership organizations or in states like New York, member approval may be required for some changes.
What happens if a nonprofit does not follow its bylaws?
Failure to follow your bylaws can lead to disputes, loss of board credibility, regulatory penalties, or even loss of tax-exempt status. It is essential to adhere to your bylaws and keep them up to date. Regulators and funders may also withhold support if your organization is not following its own rules.
Key Takeaways
- Nonprofit bylaws are essential for defining how your organization operates and who has authority.
- The board of directors typically controls the bylaws, but member approval may be required in some organizations or states.
- Bylaws should be formally adopted, amended, and recorded according to your state's requirements and your own rules.
- Proper recordkeeping is critical for compliance with IRS and state regulations.
- Regularly review and update your bylaws to avoid common mistakes and keep your nonprofit running smoothly.
- Always tailor your bylaws to your organization's needs and comply with state-specific requirements.
If you need help drafting, reviewing, or amending nonprofit bylaws, or want to ensure your organization is meeting state and federal requirements, our team can assist. Contact us at (888) 449-8437 or team@sprintlaw.com for a confidential discussion. Where legal services are required, they are delivered by licensed lawyers at trusted US law firms through the Sprintlaw platform.
