Alex is Sprintlaw's co-founder and a legal technology leader. He holds law and media degrees from the University of Sydney and has been recognized by Australasian Lawyer, Lawyers Weekly and the Sydney Young Entrepreneur Awards for his work building Sprintlaw and improving access to business legal support.
- Does a New Stockholder Have to Sign the Stockholders' Agreement?
- Is a Stockholders' Agreement Enforceable If Someone Never Signed It?
- What Happens If the Company Has Already Issued the Stock?
- Can You Ask the Stockholder to Sign a Joinder Agreement Afterwards?
- What If the New Stockholder Refuses to Sign?
- How Can Companies Avoid This Problem?
- What Should You Do If a New Stockholder Never Signed?
Bringing a new investor into your company usually involves a lot of moving parts. Between negotiations, discussions about ownership and signing documents, it's possible for something important to get overlooked.
But what happens if your new investor receives their stock without ever signing the existing stockholders' agreement?
Owning stock in a company doesn't automatically mean someone is bound by every agreement the other stockholders have signed. This can create a tricky situation where someone has ownership rights in your business but may not be subject to the same contractual obligations as everyone else.
So, can you still enforce the stockholders' agreement against them? And what can your company do if they've already received their stock?
Let's take a closer look.
Does a New Stockholder Have to Sign the Stockholders' Agreement?
A stockholders' agreement is a legally binding contract that sets out certain rights and obligations between a company's stockholders.
Depending on its terms, it may cover voting arrangements, restrictions on selling stock, confidentiality obligations and what happens when someone wants to exit the business.
Having a properly drafted stockholders' agreement can help establish clear expectations and reduce the risk of disagreements between the company's owners.
However, not everyone who owns stock in a company is necessarily a party to the same agreement. Some agreements only apply to particular founders or investors, while others require new stockholders to formally join before receiving their stock.
This is where a joinder agreement becomes important.
A joinder agreement allows a new stockholder to become a party to an existing stockholders' agreement without requiring everyone to sign an entirely new contract.
It's also worth noting that a separate joinder isn't always the only way someone can become bound. A stockholder might have agreed to the relevant terms through a subscription agreement, stock purchase agreement or another legally effective arrangement.
Whether someone is bound therefore depends on the company's documents, how the agreement was accepted and applicable state law.
Is a Stockholders' Agreement Enforceable If Someone Never Signed It?
Generally, a stockholders' agreement is enforceable against the parties who have legally agreed to its terms.
If a new stockholder hasn't signed or otherwise agreed to be bound, the company may have difficulty enforcing certain contractual obligations against them.
This can become particularly problematic when the company tries to enforce a restriction that the new stockholder doesn't believe applies to them.
Say the existing agreement requires stockholders to offer their stock to the company's other owners before selling to an outside investor.
A new stockholder later decides to sell without following that process.
Can the company prevent the sale?
Not necessarily, but the missing signature isn't the only factor that matters.
Certain restrictions may be enforceable independently of the stockholders' agreement, depending on the company's governing documents and applicable law.
Under Section 202 of the Delaware General Corporation Law, certain written restrictions on stock transfers or ownership may be enforceable against stockholders who haven't personally signed the relevant agreement.
However, there are legal requirements. These include whether the restriction is permitted by law and whether it was properly disclosed on the stock certificate or, for uncertificated stock, in the required notice. In some circumstances, the stockholder's actual knowledge of the restriction may also be relevant.
It's important to distinguish these restrictions from other contractual obligations, such as confidentiality provisions or voting agreements, which may have different enforceability requirements.
The key question isn't simply whether the stockholder signed, but whether there's a valid legal basis for enforcing the particular obligation against them.
What Happens If the Company Has Already Issued the Stock?
Discovering a missing joinder agreement after stock has already been issued can raise questions about both the stockholder's obligations and the validity of the issuance itself.
If the stock was validly issued or transferred, the person may still have the ownership rights associated with it, even if they aren't bound by every provision of the existing stockholders' agreement.
However, the position can become more complicated where signing a joinder was a mandatory condition of receiving the stock.
This isn't just a theoretical concern.
In the Delaware case Southpaw Credit Opportunity Master Fund, L.P. v. Roma Restaurant Holdings, Inc. (2018), the Court of Chancery considered a company that issued restricted stock without obtaining the joinder documents required by its existing stockholders' agreement.
Importantly, that agreement expressly prohibited the company from issuing stock without the required joinder and stated that any non-compliant issuance would be void.
The court found that the company had failed to comply with those requirements and held that the relevant stock issuance was void.
However, this doesn't mean every missing joinder automatically invalidates a stock issuance. The outcome depends on the wording of the relevant agreements, applicable state law and the circumstances surrounding the transaction.
For a company discovering this problem, it's important to review the existing stockholders' agreement, certificate of incorporation, bylaws, stock issuance or transfer documents and relevant corporate approvals.
The company should also establish whether the joinder requirement was a condition of issuing the stock, whether the new stockholder agreed to the terms elsewhere and whether the transaction was otherwise validly completed.
These details can determine what rights and remedies may be available.
Can You Ask the Stockholder to Sign a Joinder Agreement Afterwards?
Yes. If the missing agreement was simply an oversight, the company can approach the stockholder about signing a joinder agreement.
If everyone is willing to cooperate, this may help resolve uncertainty about the stockholder's obligations going forward.
However, signing afterwards doesn't automatically resolve every legal issue.
If the stockholder wasn't previously bound, a new agreement generally won't automatically make them liable for obligations that applied before they joined.
Similarly, a late signature won't necessarily cure a defective stock issuance. Depending on the circumstances, additional corporate approvals, corrective documents or statutory procedures may be required.
The company should therefore establish whether the original issuance was valid before assuming that signing the missing document will resolve the situation.
What If the New Stockholder Refuses to Sign?
This is where the situation can become more difficult.
If the stockholder hasn't already agreed to join the existing agreement, the company cannot necessarily force them to accept new contractual obligations simply because they own stock.
However, the position may be different if the stockholder previously signed another enforceable agreement requiring them to join.
In that situation, refusing to sign could potentially amount to a breach of an existing contractual obligation.
The company would need to review the relevant documents to determine whether there has been a breach and what remedies might be available.
It's also important not to assume the company can simply cancel the person's stock, remove their voting rights or prevent a transfer because they refuse to cooperate.
Those actions require an appropriate legal basis, and taking them without first establishing the stockholder's rights could create further disputes.
Depending on the circumstances, the parties may be able to negotiate a new agreement or address the issue through an existing contractual remedy.
Where the dispute concerns ownership, voting rights or the validity of an issuance, legal advice should be obtained before the company attempts to take action.
How Can Companies Avoid This Problem?
Ideally, joinder requirements should be addressed before stock is issued or transferred.
When bringing in an investor, issuing equity to an employee or approving a stock transfer, companies should check whether their existing agreements require the incoming stockholder to formally join them.
It's also important to make sure the transaction documents are consistent.
For instance, if an investor is required to join the stockholders' agreement before receiving their stock, that requirement should be properly addressed in the relevant subscription and stockholders' agreement or other transaction documentation.
Companies should also maintain accurate records of signed agreements, corporate approvals and stock ownership.
If you've already discovered a missing document, reviewing the situation early may help prevent a relatively straightforward oversight from developing into a more complicated ownership dispute.
What Should You Do If a New Stockholder Never Signed?
If you've discovered that a new stockholder hasn't signed the existing agreement, it's worth having the relevant documents reviewed before attempting to enforce restrictions or make changes to their rights.
The consequences will depend on how the transaction was completed, what the company's documents require and which state laws apply. Some contractual obligations may be difficult to enforce, while a missing mandatory joinder could raise questions about the stock issuance itself.
Sprintlaw can help you coordinate legal support for reviewing your stockholders' agreement and addressing stock ownership documentation.
If you'd like to discuss your options, contact us on (888) 449-8437 or team@sprintlaw.com for a free, no-obligation chat.








